Case 5.19: The Fight

Chakotay’s whole life was a million-to-one shot, but this time, he’s fighting not for glory, not for money, but for love (of ship and crew). His fights have been easy, but an upstart (alien) is going to make him prove just how far he can still go. The only thing he can’t do is walk away (because the ship is stuck in chaotic space). He’ll find out that legacy is more than just a name (or whatever madness his grandad might have passed along). Lace ‘em up and take it to the mattresses to find out if “The Fight” is GOOD… or GARBAGE!

Case 5.19: The Fight
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.18: Course: Oblivion

It’s the shocking sequel to season 4’s “Demon” that absolutely no one demanded! The crew of Voyager discovers that they are actually the gooey clone crew of gooey clone Voyager, and their advanced gooey clone warp drive is slowly melting them at the molecular level! Will the crew choose hard reality over assumed identity in time to find safe harbor? Will gooey Janeway indulge the impulse for pointless self-annihilation that real Janeway keeps tidily suppressed? Will anyone discover and/or give a crap about what ultimately becomes of these posers? Is “Course: Oblivion” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.18: Course: Oblivion
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.17: The Disease

Ensign Kim ain’t got a fever, got a permanent disease, and it’ll take more than the Doctor to prescribe a remedy! He’s got lots of duties but it isn’t what he needs, and he don’t wanna take a shot to set his serotonin free! He’s got all the symptoms, count’ em, 1-2-3, first he sneaks (that’s what you get for falling in love!), then he freaks (you get a little and it’s never enough)! Now Ensign Kim’s addicted and Tal’s kiss is the drug, whoa-oh-oh, her love is like BAAAAAD MEDICINE, but BAD MEDICINE results in an official reprimand. Is Case 5.17: The Disease GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.17: The Disease
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.15 and 5.16: Dark Frontier - Parts 1 & 2

It’s Dark Frontier on the Drunk Frontier, and the quality of the discussion is more dubious than ever! Voyager finally offers up the Hansen family backstory long demanded by the masses, but will it be enough to save this movie-length tale from the rum-soaked scorn of the court? Can the Borg be outfoxed again? Will Janeway and Seven upgrade their dynamic from “contentious” to “romantically contentious?” Is “Dark Frontier” GOOD... or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.15 and 5.16: Dark Frontier - Parts 1 & 2
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.14: Bliss

When the Voyager crew finds all of their most modest dreams kind of coming true, stalwart buzzkill Seven of Nine must weaponize her skepticism to save the ship from the big worm thing behind the illusion. Will Seven learn the importance of trusting weird, old strangers? Will she be able to convince the crew that their lives still sort of suck? Will the writers really try to pass this off as a Moby Dick analog in the third act? Is “Bliss” GOOD... or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.14: Bliss
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.13: Gravity

When one of the old, crappy shuttles crash lands inside a time-distorting gravity well, Tuvok falls in love in a hopeless place with the ace pitcher for the Racine Belles. Can Tom convince him to drop his Vulcan chill and swing for the fences? Will Voyager rescue them all before the gravity well crushes the most subtle romance in Delta Quadrant history? Is “Gravity” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.13: Gravity
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.12: Bride of Chaotica

In space, no one can hear you laugh maniacally! When explorers from a dimension of pure light start a war with Tom’s favorite video game, Janeway must bravely don a kinky golden-age science fiction getup to bring fire to a villain's loins and peace back to the holodeck. Can the power of amateur theater save these hapless photonic wanderers from the wrath of Chaotica? Will Captain Proton hang up his cardboard jetpack for good? Will Janeway hang on to that costume for, uh, special occasions? Will the smug and infuriatingly soft-spoken panel of experts on WPSTV find the charming cultural artifact known as “Bride of Chaotica” to be HARMLESS… or HARMFUL?

Case 5.12: Bride of Chaotica!
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.11: Latent Image

A mysterious scar on the back of Harry Kim’s head sends the Doctor down a path of conspiracy towards the realization of a devastating truth. Also, there’s a high-level argument about sumo wrestling. Did the Doctor sacrifice the life of everyone’s favorite ensign we never met to save the life of everyone’s not-favorite ensign we meet a little too often? Can the Doctor survive a run-in with persistent moral uncertainty? Was Janeway actually at that sumo match, or is she doing that thing where you pretend you were at something just to sound cool but then you get called on it? Is “Latent Image” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.11: Latent Image
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.10: Counterpoint

With danger nipping at their heels, the crew of Voyager smuggles two Vulcans and a bunch of telepathic refugees through the territory of the generically authoritarian Devore Empire! With loneliness nipping at her heels, Janeway considers smuggling a handsome and well-cultured Devore officer into her quarters! Will Voyager get the refugees through the convenient wormhole in time? Can the captain find love in the time of fascism? Will all this flirtin’ end in a double-cross, a triple-cross, or possibly even the rare quadruple-cross? Is “Counterpoint” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.10: Counterpoint
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.9: Thirty Days

Judge Janeway sentences Cool Hand Tom to thirty days of psychological torture for the egregious crime of doing stuff that almost every other member of the crew has already done without penalty! Will Paris realize that only Janeway and her closest buds are allowed to wrap fish with the Prime Directive? Will he catch up on his family correspondences? Will we finally get the Delaney Sisters spin-off we so richly deserve? Is “Thirty Days” GOOD... or is it garbage?

Case 5.9: Thirty Days
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.8: Nothing Human

 Series co-creator Jeri Taylor ends her run in the Voyager writers room by saddling B’Elanna with a big ol’ nasty space bug and saddling the rest of the crew with a big ol’ nasty ethical quandary. Is a helpful holographic manifestation of a Cardassian war criminal morally distinct from a Cardassian war criminal? If good is accomplished using knowledge obtained by evil means, is the good now bad? Will somebody please chunk that gross bug puppet out the airlock? Is “Nothing Human” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.8: Nothing Human
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.7: Infinite Regress

It’s another super weird day on Voyager when a biotech weapon meant to eradicate the Evil Borg causes their Good Borg to manifest the personalities of her previous victims. Can the team shut the weapon down in time to save Seven and avert a diplomatic disaster? Will Seven survive this forced reconciliation with her murderous past? Will the whole thing come off like a community theater production of “Sybil in Space?” Is “Infinite Regress” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.7: Infinite Regress
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.6: Timeless - EXTREME POTTY-MOUTH WARNING!

Things get all bearded and gritty as future hard-ass Harry Kim hijacks the timeline to fix a math mistake and rescue Voyager from its frozen grave! Chakotay and his new girlfriend go along with his plan for some reason! Can a Captain LaForge (!!!) cameo save this episode from the metaphorical ice planet of a garbage verdict? Will Future Harry use the miracle of Borg quantum communication to call Present Harry a lil’ dweeb? Is “Timeless” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.6: Timeless
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.5: Once Upon a Time

Hey there, little voyagers! Do you know what time it is? That’s right! It’s time for more scene-by-scene critical analysis of Star Trek: Voyager! Hooray! This week’s episode of Voyager examines anxieties related to death and loss through the lens of children’s literature, because of course it does! Will Naomi Wildman successfully cope with the possible loss of her mother when an away mission goes wrong? Can her imaginary friend be reconstituted after a fire ogre blasts him to steam? Will Neelix make the whole thing about him and his issues? Is “Once Upon a Time” GOOD... or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.5: Once Upon a Time
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager


Case 5.4: In the Flesh

Voyager stumbles upon a perfect recreation of Starfleet Academy in the middle of Delta Quadrant, leaving them no choice but to activate Solid Chakotay for some intense undercover recon with a little alien-smoochin’ on the side. Will anything happen in this episode beyond what was described in the previous sentence? What are the limits of diplomacy? How many times can we whisper “in the flesh” in a single, hour-long episode? Is “In the Flesh” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.4: In the Flesh
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.3: Extreme Risk

B’Elanna’s losses and traumas provoke a wicked bout of depression and dangerous coping behaviors, leaving her clueless friends on Voyager absolutely and inexplicably befuddled as to why she isn’t her usual, ebullient self. Can they connect the very connectable dots in time to help her gain some emotional footing? What the hell is up with attitudes toward mental health in the 24th century? For that matter, what the hell was up with attitudes toward mental health in the late 20th century? Does the Delta Flyer look cool? Is “Extreme Risk” GOOD… or is it GARBAGE?  

Case 5.3: Extreme Risk
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.2: Drone

When the Doctor’s mobile emitter gets a Borg nanoprobe infusion and steals neck DNA from Ensign Mulchaey (just roll with it), the resulting Baby Borg puts Seven’s emotional well-being right back in the crosshairs. Can she impart her emerging humanity onto the most tricked-out drone to ever live? Will Janeway get impatient and toss the kid out the nearest airlock? Is “Drone” GOOD... or is it GARBAGE?

Case 5.2: Drone
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Case 5.1: Night

SHIELDS UP! For the first time since August, we can see justice on long-range sensors! The People vs. Star Trek Voyager warps out of hiatus with its SPECIAL 100th EPISODE CELEBRATION! New meta-plot developments! Listener shoutouts and on-air Q&A! Cake! And, of yeah, justice lovingly rendered for Voyager’s season 5 premiere! Resume the journey to finally find out if “Night” is GOOD... or GARBAGE!

Case 5.1: Night
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Special Presentation - A Podcast Pilot! AGAIN! - The People v. Gundam Wing - Episode 2!

Gundam Wing’s writers roll out an episode title that is certifiably metal af! Heero stunts on horseback! The noble quest for clarity takes our courtroom warriors from the depths of the ocean to a super-awkward birthday party and to all the roadside circuses and rich-boy picnics in between! Will Zechs and his gang of lovable oafs scam their way to the powerful robo-treasure napping on the floor of the sea? Will Relena unravel the mystery of the handsome stranger at her prep school who would rather kill her than go to her boring-ass party? How many episodes will it take for Judge Josh to learn the names of all the Handsome Murder Boys? Is Episode 2, “Gundam Deathscythe,” RAD… or is it BAD?

Special Presentation - A Podcast Pilot! AGAIN! - The People v. Gundam Wing - Episode 2
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager

Special Presentation - A Podcast Pilot! - The People v. Gundam Wing

A solar system stands on the edge of war as tensions between Earth and her unruly colonies strain to a breaking point. The only thing that can heal the divide is an answer to the unanswerable question: Is Mobile Suit Gundam Wing rad… or is it bad? Join two dueling anime aficionados and a guy who can definitely point to Japan on a map as they dive into season 1 of Gundam Wing, braving the tempestuous sea of murder boys, giant robot warriors, and questionable line readings in search of elusive truth-- one action-packed episode at a time!    

Special Presentation - A Podcast Pilot! - The People v. Gundam Wing
The People v. Star Trek: Voyager